Current:Home > MarketsThe Supreme Court ponders when a threat is really a 'true threat'-Angel Dreamer Wealth Society D1 Reviews & Insights
The Supreme Court ponders when a threat is really a 'true threat'
View Date:2024-12-23 18:53:25
The Supreme Court on Wednesday revisits a question the court has never answered: When is a threat a "true threat?" What does the prosecution have to prove? Does it have to show that the defendant intended to frighten his target, or is it enough to show that his words would have that effect on a reasonable person?
The case involves Coles Whalen, a singer-songwriter from Colorado, and Billy Counterman, a man convicted and sentenced to four-and-a-half years in prison for "stalking" Whalen and making "true threats" against her.
How the messages escalated
Counterman's messages to Whalen began in 2010 and heated up to a full boil in 2014, when police estimate he sent over a thousand messages to the singer — messages that ranged from affectionate to angry and aggressive, and gave the impression he was watching her.
"He was clearly mentally unstable," Whalen said in an interview with NPR. "He believed that we were in a romantic relationship that lasted a number of years. He indicated that he was seeing me in person without me knowing it. And I was terrified."
At one point, Counterman inquired about her mother after Whalen had just paid her mom a visit. At another, he wrote, "Die. Don't need you," and in another message he wrote, "I'm currently unsupervised. I know, it freaks me out too."
Whalen repeatedly blocked him from her Facebook account, but he would create new accounts, even contacting her bandmates about her. She became so scared that he would emerge from a crowd, potentially lunging at her on stage, that she stopped publicizing her appearances, varied her routes, hired a body guard on one occasion and bought a pepper spray gun that she keeps with her to this day.
Whalen's anxiety escalated further when she learned that Counterman had served two jail terms for far more explicitly violent threats against his ex-wife and family. But even after he was arrested, her fear persisted. Her first panic attack came in Dallas, when she was performing in front of about 300 people.
"I thought I might be having a heart attack ... and I had to leave the stage, which I've never done in all my years performing," Whalen said. "When I went backstage, I mean, I just sobbed for an hour. I felt so horrible. I thought, maybe this isn't worth it. Maybe I shouldn't continue."
What the legal questions are
The legal issues in Wednesday's case are bloodless compared to Whalen's story. The First Amendment protects freedom of speech, but there are exceptions — obscenity, fighting words, falsely shouting "fire" in a crowded theater and what the court has called "true threats." The question in this case is whether the definition of a "true threat" is in the eye of the ordinary, reasonable beholder or in the eye of the writer of the messages.
Lawyer John Elwood, who is representing Counterman in the Supreme Court, points out that his client has been diagnosed with a mental illness and didn't know that he was frightening Whalen.
"A 'true threat' standard that considers the speaker's intent is necessary to avoid criminalizing inevitable misunderstandings," he wrote in his brief. To illustrate the point, he notes that if you hit someone accidentally, you may bruise that person, but that's not a crime. But if you hit someone on purpose, that is a crime.
Noting that early English and American decisions required proof of the speaker's intent, Elwood argues that in the internet age, "words on the screen are divorced from context."
The First Amendment, he contends, doesn't allow the state to punish a person based on what a reasonable person receiving a message might think. The question is what the speaker intends.
That argument is supported by a variety of civil liberties groups. The Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, for instance, points to several examples of journalists being charged under stalking laws for leaving voicemail messages for public officials or approaching them at home to get responses for stories.
The ACLU argues that political hyperbole can often be mistaken for a genuine threat. Without a demonstration of intent, the organization argues, "one person's opprobrium may be another's threat." It adds that the fact that many of these statements occur online "underscores the need for a subjective intent requirement."
A sign of the times?
Colorado Attorney General Philip Weiser counters that under Colorado law, the question is whether an objective person in the situation of the victim would feel threatened. And, he notes, that's what the trial was about in the Counterman case.
"Since the founding of the Republic, we've had threat statutes that have allowed the prosecution of threats without regard to the specific intent of the person making the threats," Weiser said, in an interview with NPR.
He points to briefs filed by victims' rights organizations and studies showing that, for the victim, the psychological effects of threatening behavior is frequently far worse than an actual assault.
"We live in a time of rising demonization and threats of physical violence and actual physical violence," Weiser said. "It's important that the law be able to respond."
Indeed, in the aftermath of the Supreme Court's abortion decision, the justices themselves have experienced a large increase in threats.
As for Whalen, even after Counterman's conviction, she couldn't shake her fear.
"I truly expected to get back out there and be the same me, the old me, that had been performing all these years," she said. "A great shock to me was to learn that I was not that person anymore, and I was going to have to find another way to perform as this new person that I had become through this traumatic experience."
Initially, she gave up performing, moved far away, found a great therapist, got married and had two children. She has now clawed her way back psychologically to performing again, though sometimes tremulously.
"I'm not hiding anymore," read the lyrics of "Stronger," a song she wrote this year. "It would have been easy to fade away. I've decided I've got more to say. I'm singing out loud a little stronger than I did before. I'm singing out loud."
A decision in the "true threats" case is expected by summer.
veryGood! (4551)
Related
- LSU student arrested over threats to governor who wanted a tiger at college football games
- Justin Fields' surprising admission on Bears' coaches cranks up pressure on entire franchise
- AP PHOTOS: King Charles and Camilla share moments both regal and ordinary on landmark trip to France
- Taiwan factory fire leaves at least 5 dead, more than 100 injured
- The Daily Money: All about 'Doge.'
- Why can't babies have honey? The answer lies in microscopic spores.
- After climate summit, California Gov. Gavin Newsom faces key decisions to reduce emissions back home
- Taiwan factory fire leaves at least 5 dead, more than 100 injured
- Giuliani’s lawyers after $148M defamation judgment seek to withdraw from his case
- As the world’s diplomacy roils a few feet away, a little UN oasis offers a riverside pocket of peace
Ranking
- One person is dead after a shooting at Tuskegee University
- Why are people on TikTok asking men how often they think about the Roman Empire?
- Nevada Republicans have set rules for their presidential caucus seen as helping Donald Trump
- Are you Latino if you can't speak Spanish? Here's what Latinos say
- Hurricane-stricken Tampa Bay Rays to play 2025 season at Yankees’ spring training field in Tampa
- Tropical Storm Ophelia tracks up East Coast, downing trees and flooding roads
- California bill to have humans drivers ride in autonomous trucks is vetoed by governor
- Indiana woman stabs baby niece while attempting to stab dog for eating chicken sandwich
Recommendation
-
Target will be closed on Thanksgiving: Here’s when stores open on Black Friday
-
Auto workers still have room to expand their strike against car makers. But they also face risks
-
Workers exit GM facilities targeted as expanded UAW strikes get underway
-
UNGA Briefing: Nagorno-Karabakh, Lavrov and what else is going on at the UN
-
Wicked's Ethan Slater Shares How Ariana Grande and Cynthia Erivo Set the Tone on Set
-
What to know about NASA's OSIRIS-REx asteroid sample return mission
-
Deion Sanders' pastor and friend walks the higher walk with Coach Prime before every Colorado game
-
UK regulators clear way for Microsoft and Activision merger