Current:Home > MarketsColorado court upholds Google keyword search warrant which led to arrests in fatal arson-Angel Dreamer Wealth Society D1 Reviews & Insights
Colorado court upholds Google keyword search warrant which led to arrests in fatal arson
View Date:2024-12-23 15:48:59
DENVER (AP) — Colorado’s highest court on Monday upheld the search of Google users’ keyword history to identify suspects in a 2020 fatal arson fire, an approach that critics have called a digital dragnet that threatens to undermine people’s privacy and their constitutional protections against unreasonable searches and seizures.
However the Colorado Supreme Court cautioned it was not making a “broad proclamation” on the constitutionality of such warrants and emphasized it was ruling on the facts of just this one case.
At issue before the court was a search warrant from Denver police requiring Google to provide the IP addresses of anyone who had searched over 15 days for the address of the home that was set on fire, killing five immigrants from the West African nation of Senegal.
After some back and forth over how Google would be able to provide information without violating its privacy policy, Google produced a spreadsheet of sixty-one searches made by eight accounts. Google provided the IP addresses for those accounts, but no names. Five of the IP addresses were based in Colorado and police obtained the names of those people through another search warrant. After investigating those people, police eventually identified three teens as suspects.
One of them, Gavin Seymour, asked the court to throw the evidence out because it violated the Fourth Amendment’s ban on unreasonable searches and seizures by being overbroad and not being targeted against a specific person suspected of a crime.
Search warrants to gather evidence are typically sought once police have identified a suspect and gathered some probable cause to believe they committed a crime. But in this case, the trail had run cold and police were seeking a “reverse keyword” warrant for the Google search history in a quest to identify possible suspects. Since the attack seemed targeted, investigators believed whoever set fire to the house would have searched for directions to it.
The state Supreme Court ruled that Seymour had a constitutionally protected privacy interest in his Google search history even though it was just connected with an IP address and not his name. While it also said it assumes that the warrant was “constitutionally defective” for not specifying an “individualized probable cause”, the court said it would not throw out the evidence because police were acting in good faith under what was known about the law at the time.
The court said it was not aware of any other state supreme court or federal appellate court that has dealt with this type of warrant before.
“Our finding of good faith today neither condones nor condemns all such warrants in the future. If dystopian problems emerge, as some fear, the courts stand ready to hear argument regarding how we should rein in law enforcement’s use of rapidly advancing technology. Today, we proceed incrementally based on the facts before us,” it said.
In a dissent, Justice Monica Marquez said such a wide-ranging search of a billion Google users’ search history without a particular target is exactly the kind the Fourth Amendment was designed to stop.
“At the risk of sounding alarmist, I fear that by upholding this practice, the majority’s ruling today gives constitutional cover to law enforcement seeking unprecedented access to the private lives of individuals not just in Colorado, but across the globe. And I fear that today’s decision invites courts nationwide to do the same,” she said in the dissent, which Justice Carlos Samour joined in.
In a statement, Google said it was important that the court’s ruling recognized the privacy and First Amendment interests involved in keyword searches.
“With all law enforcement demands, including reverse warrants, we have a rigorous process designed to protect the privacy of our users while supporting the important work of law enforcement,” it said.
The ruling allows the prosecution of Seymour and Kevin Bui, who were 16 at the time of the Aug. 5, 2020, fire, to move ahead in adult court on charges of first-degree murder, attempted murder, arson and burglary. Investigators allege Bui organized the attack on the home because he mistakenly believed people who had stolen his iPhone during a robbery lived there.
Telephone messages and an email sent to Seymour’s lawyers, Jenifer Stinson and Michael Juba, were not immediately returned. A lawyer for Bui, Christian Earle, could not be reached for comment.
A third teen, Dillon Siebert, who was 14 at the time and originally charged as a juvenile, pleaded guilty earlier this year to second-degree murder in adult court under a deal that prosecutors and the defense said balanced his lesser role in planning the fire, his remorse and interest in rehabilitation with the horror of the crime. He was sentenced to 10 years behind bars.
veryGood! (87224)
Related
- Bev Priestman fired as Canada women’s soccer coach after review of Olympic drone scandal
- Meals on Wheels rolling at 50, bringing food, connections, sunshine to seniors
- On wild Los Angeles night, Padres bully Dodgers to tie NLDS – with leg up heading home
- San Jose State women's volleyball team has been thrown into debate after forfeits
- Wisconsin’s high court to hear oral arguments on whether an 1849 abortion ban remains valid
- TikToker Taylor Rousseau Grigg Dead at Age 25
- Guster, Avett Brothers and Florence Welch are helping bring alt-rock to the musical theater stage
- Andy Kim and Curtis Bashaw clash over abortion and immigration in New Jersey Senate debate
- To Protect the Ozone Layer and Slow Global Warming, Fertilizers Must Be Deployed More Efficiently, UN Says
- Ex-Delaware officer sentenced to probation on assault conviction
Ranking
- Padma Lakshmi, John Boyega, Hunter Schafer star in Pirelli's 2025 calendar: See the photos
- San Jose State women's volleyball team has been thrown into debate after forfeits
- TikToker Taylor Rousseau Grigg Dead at Age 25
- Bruins free-agent goaltender Jeremy Swayman signs 8-year, $66 million deal
- Atlanta man dies in shootout after police chase that also kills police dog
- Michigan gun owner gets more than 3 years in prison for accidental death of grandson
- Clint Eastwood's Daughter Morgan Gives Birth, Welcomes First Baby With Tanner Koopmans
- NFL’s Buccaneers relocating ahead of hurricane to practice for Sunday’s game at New Orleans
Recommendation
-
NCT DREAM enters the 'DREAMSCAPE': Members on new album, its concept and songwriting
-
'We know we're good': Mets pounce after Phillies pull ace in latest rousing comeback
-
NFL games today: Start time, TV info for Sunday's Week 5 matchups
-
Lakers' Bronny James focusing on 'being a pest on defense' in preseason
-
Investigation into Chinese hacking reveals ‘broad and significant’ spying effort, FBI says
-
Opinion: Kalen DeBoer won't soon live down Alabama's humiliating loss to Vanderbilt
-
Billie Jean King named grand marshal for the 136th Rose Parade on Jan. 1
-
Pilot dies in a crash of a replica WWI-era plane in upstate New York