Current:Home > MySome states reject federal money to find and replace dangerous lead pipes-Angel Dreamer Wealth Society D1 Reviews & Insights
Some states reject federal money to find and replace dangerous lead pipes
View Date:2024-12-23 22:49:26
ST. LOUIS (AP) — As the Biden administration makes billions of dollars available to remove millions of dangerous lead pipes that can contaminate drinking water and damage brain development in children, some states are turning down funds.
Washington, Oregon, Maine and Alaska declined all or most of their federal funds in the first of five years that the mix of grants and loans is available, The Associated Press found. Some states are less prepared to pay for lead removal projects because, in many cases, the lead must first be found, experts said. And communities are hesitant to take out loans to search for their lead pipes.
States shouldn’t “shrug their shoulders” and pass up funds, said Erik Olson, a health and food expert at the environmental group Natural Resources Defense Council.
“It’s troubling that a state would decide to take a complete pass on the funding because part of the reason for the funding is to figure out whether you even have lead,” Olson said.
The Biden administration wants to remove all 9.2 million lead pipes carrying water to U.S. homes. Lead can lower IQ and create behavioral problems in children. The 2021 infrastructure law provides $15 billion to find and replace them. That money will help a lot, but it isn’t enough to get all the toxic pipes out of the ground. State programs distribute the federal funds to utilities.
The Environmental Protection Agency said it is reviewing state requests to decline funds but did not provide a full list of states that have said no so far. That information will be available in October, officials said. States that declined first-year funds can still accept them during the remaining four years.
“EPA has been working closely with our state partners on utilizing Bipartisan Infrastructure Law funding that is available,” the agency said.
Lead pipes are far more common in some states such as Michigan and Illinois, which each have hundreds of thousands. The harm there is clear. Flint’s lead crisis elevated lead in tap water to a national health issue. Residents of Benton Harbor, Michigan, drank water with too much lead for years until all their lead pipes were replaced. In response, however, Michigan is clamoring for as much money as it can get to remove lead.
The states that declined funds have fewer problematic pipes, but that doesn’t mean lead isn’t an issue. There’s concern about lead in some Maine schools. Portland, Oregon, has struggled with high lead levels for years, although recent tests have been better and officials say the issue isn’t lead pipes, but household plumbing.
Washington accepted $85,000 of $63 million it could have taken and said the decision was based on the limited number of water systems that wanted loans. The EPA estimates the state has 22,000 lead pipes. Oregon, which could have accepted $37 million, said inventories are going to be done with existing staff and resources, adding that utilities have no known lead lines. The EPA projected that the state has 3,530 lead pipes — a relatively small number — based in part on information collected from utilities.
The location of many lead pipes is a mystery. The EPA is requiring communities to provide initial inventories of their lead pipes by October 2024. Maine, which banned lead pipes far earlier than most states, said other funds would be used for inventories and they didn’t have lead replacement projects ready to fund. Most states that rejected funding initially indicated they would probably ask for money in later years.
To access the grants, there also needs to be demand for loans but utilities are hesitant to seek them out, according to Deirdre Finn, executive director of the Council of Infrastructure Financing Authorities, a group that represents the federally funded state programs that distribute infrastructure funds.
“This is a great opportunity,” Finn said. “But it would be helpful if states and utilities had access to 100% grant funding to move these projects along.”
Federal funds can only go to replacement projects that remove the entire lead pipe. Lead pipes run from the water main in the street to homes, but the ownership of the pipe is often split between the utility and homeowner. Some cities replace just the portion they own — a harmful practice that spikes lead levels — and paying to replace the homeowner’s side is often a problem. Grants can help utilities pay to replace the homeowner’s side, Finn said.
The EPA offered early funds based on a state’s general drinking water infrastructure needs — not the number of lead pipes. The EPA later developed estimates of each state’s lead pipes to inform how future years of funding should be distributed. Therefore, some states were offered more early money than they can spend.
In May, for example, Alaska told the EPA it wanted just $6.8 million of the $28 million it was entitled to receive. Carrie Bohan, facilities program manager in the division of water at the Alaska Department of Environmental Conservation, said utilities’ demand for loans to inventory their systems for lead pipes is “very, very small.” But over five years, there will be plenty of federal funds available to find the small number of lead pipes in Alaska and replace them.
Money that’s not used will be redistributed to other states that need it.
“I think it’s a potential disservice to other states if we were to apply for the full amount knowing that we couldn’t make use of it,” Bohan said.
But just figuring out how to distribute the money based on need is difficult. In April, the EPA’s lead pipe estimate surprised some experts by predicting that Florida had 1.16 million, the most of any state.
The higher estimate meant Florida would get more funds, but the state objected, arguing its utilities would find far more lead in the tap water if it really had that many lead pipes.
“Once these lead line surveys are completed, it is expected that the actual extent of facilities with lead service lines documented in Florida will be significantly less than what was estimated by the EPA,” said Brian Miller, a spokesperson with the Florida Department of Environmental Protection.
___
The Associated Press receives support from the Walton Family Foundation for coverage of water and environmental policy. The AP is solely responsible for all content. For all of AP’s environmental coverage, visit https://apnews.com/hub/climate-and-environment
veryGood! (17)
Related
- Democrat Janelle Bynum flips Oregon’s 5th District, will be state’s first Black member of Congress
- Cute Fall Sweaters Under $50 on Amazon (That You'll Want in Every Color)
- Fantasy football Start ‘Em, Sit ‘Em: 16 players to start or sit in Week 2
- Two workers trapped in South Dakota silo are believed killed by toxic gas
- Surfer Bethany Hamilton Makes Masked Singer Debut After 3-Year-Old Nephew’s Tragic Death
- Poverty in the U.S. increased last year, even as incomes rose, Census Bureau says
- Flash flood sweeps away hamlet as Vietnam’s storm toll rises to 155 dead
- What to know about the panic buttons used by staff members at Apalachee High School
- Drone footage captures scope of damage, destruction from deadly Louisville explosion
- Dave Grohl Reveals He Fathered Baby Outside of Marriage to Jordyn Blum
Ranking
- Kate Spade Outlet’s Early Black Friday Sale – Get a $259 Bag for $59 & More Epic Deals Starting at $25
- US consumer watchdog finds that school lunch fees are taking a toll on parents
- Prison guard shortfall makes it harder for inmates to get reprieve from extreme heat, critics say
- Katy Perry Reacts to Viral Photo of Orlando Bloom Appearing to Check Out Kim Kardashian
- Mike Tyson impresses crowd during workout ahead of Jake Paul fight
- NFL investigating lawsuit filed against Browns quarterback Deshaun Watson, accused of sexual assault
- MTV’s Teen Mom Reveals How Amber Portwood Handled the Disappearance of Then-Fiancé Gary Wayt
- Why Raygun is now the top-ranked women's breakdancer in the world
Recommendation
-
Repair Hair Damage In Just 90 Seconds With This Hack from WNBA Star Kamilla Cardoso
-
Check Out All the Couples You Forgot Attended the MTV VMAs
-
Flash Sale: 50% Off Kylie Cosmetics High Gloss, Tan-Luxe Drops, Too Faced Lip Liner & $8.50 Ulta Deals
-
Dallas juvenile detention center isolated kids and falsified documents, state investigation says
-
Olivia Munn began randomly drug testing John Mulaney during her first pregnancy
-
Investigators probe Indiana plane crash that killed pilot, 82
-
US inflation likely fell further last month as Fed prepares to cut rates next week
-
Judge allows a man serving a 20-year prison sentence to remain on Alaska ballot