Current:Home > MyUS magistrate cites intentional evidence destruction in recommending default judgment in jail suit-Angel Dreamer Wealth Society D1 Reviews & Insights
US magistrate cites intentional evidence destruction in recommending default judgment in jail suit
View Date:2024-12-23 18:25:59
CHARLESTON, W.Va. (AP) — A federal magistrate judge cited the intentional destruction of records in recommending a default judgment in a civil rights lawsuit over conditions at a West Virginia jail.
U.S. Magistrate Judge Omar J. Alboulhosn’s order Monday evening followed a hearing in early October in which former and current corrections officials, including some defendants in the lawsuit, said that no steps were taken to preserve evidence, including emails and documents, at the Southern Regional Jail in Beaver.
Alboulhosn asked that U.S. District Judge Frank Volk find for the plaintiffs in the class-action lawsuit, noting the recommendation “is extraordinary, but clearly warranted considering the intentional conduct in this case.”
The magistrate judge also ordered that the Division of Corrections and Rehabilitation purchase hard drives to preserve the jail’s video recordings effective immediately.
Alboulhosn said listening to witnesses describe that laws and regulations governing the preservation of evidence were not followed was “some of the most remarkable testimony” that he has heard.
The magistrate judge said he “believes the failure to preserve the evidence that was destroyed in this case was intentionally done and not simply an oversight by the witnesses. The Court does not make that statement flippantly but after much thought and reflection of the disturbing testimony that took place that day.”
State corrections commissioner Betsy Jividen, the jail’s superintendent and others left their jobs in the months after the lawsuit was filed. As a result, their email accounts were removed, according to testimony at the hearing.
Brian Abraham, the chief of staff for Republican Gov. Jim Justice, has said no one in the administration sought to have emails deleted in any agency. Abraham placed blame on an attorney who was aware of the litigation, could have stopped the deletions and “failed to do so.”
In the 2022 lawsuit, current and former inmates described jail conditions as inhumane. The suit references a lack of access to water and food, as well as overcrowded conditions and fights that were allowed to continue until someone was injured.
Justice said an investigation found no evidence of inhumane treatment at the jail. The Republican governor ordered the investigation after a television station reported allegations of water deprivation, failure to provide toilet paper and inmates having to sleep on hard floors without a mattress.
veryGood! (75215)
Related
- DWTS’ Ilona Maher and Alan Bersten Have the Best Reaction to Fans Hoping for a Romance
- Warming Trends: Nature and Health Studies Focused on the Privileged, $1B for Climate School and Old Tires Detour Into Concrete
- You Don’t Need to Buy a Vowel to Enjoy Vanna White's Style Evolution
- SpaceX wants this supersized rocket to fly. But will investors send it to the Moon?
- Father sought in Amber Alert killed by officer, daughter unharmed after police chase in Ohio
- President Biden: Climate champion or fossil fuel friend?
- Get Your Skincare Routine Ready for Summer With This $12 Ice Roller That Shoppers Say Feels Amazing
- In BuzzFeed fashion, 5 takeaways from Ben Smith's 'Traffic'
- Harriet Tubman posthumously honored as general in Veterans Day ceremony: 'Long overdue'
- Shares of smaller lenders sink once again, reviving fears about the banking sector
Ranking
- Padma Lakshmi, John Boyega, Hunter Schafer star in Pirelli's 2025 calendar: See the photos
- Indian Court Rules That Nature Has Legal Status on Par With Humans—and That Humans Are Required to Protect It
- Study Identifies Outdoor Air Pollution as the ‘Largest Existential Threat to Human and Planetary Health’
- As SpaceX Grows, So Do Complaints From Environmentalists, Indigenous Groups and Brownsville Residents
- Mike Tyson vs. Jake Paul press conference highlights: 'Problem Child' goads 'Iron Mike'
- The best picket signs of the Hollywood writers strike
- Kyle Richards and Mauricio Umansky Break Up After 27 Years of Marriage
- Influencer Jackie Miller James Is Awake After Coma and Has Been Reunited With Her Baby
Recommendation
-
Asian sesame salad sold in Wegmans supermarkets recalled over egg allergy warning
-
Pregnant Lindsay Lohan Shares New Selfie as She Celebrates Her 37th Birthday
-
Financier buys Jeffrey Epstein's private islands, with plans to create a resort
-
BaubleBar 4th of July Sale: These $10 Deals Are Red, White and Cute
-
Kyle Richards Swears This Holiday Candle Is the Best Scent Ever and She Uses It All Year
-
Should EPA Back-Off Pollution Controls to Help LNG Exports Replace Russian Gas in Germany?
-
Kyle Richards and Mauricio Umansky Address “Untrue” Divorce Rumors
-
FERC Says it Will Consider Greenhouse Gas Emissions and ‘Environmental Justice’ Impacts in Approving New Natural Gas Pipelines