Current:Home > Scams'Murder in Boston' is what a docuseries should look like-Angel Dreamer Wealth Society D1 Reviews & Insights
'Murder in Boston' is what a docuseries should look like
View Date:2024-12-23 23:14:51
Monday night, HBO aired the first of three installments in its documentary series Murder in Boston: Roots, Rage & Reckoning. Directed by Jason Hehir (who made The Last Dance), it's about the October 1989 murder of Carol Stuart. The murder was originally reported by her husband, Charles, as a carjacking by a Black assailant in which they had both been shot. She died, as did the baby she was carrying. By January, Charles' brother confessed that he had assisted Charles in murdering his wife and that Charles' own injury was essentially a misdirect; the carjacker never existed. In the intervening months, a manhunt had resulted in the police stopping, searching and harassing large numbers of Black men in Boston, one of whom they even arrested. Charles Stuart identified him as the — as it turns out — fictional murderer, then took his own life shortly after his brother gave him up to the police.
There is an obvious way this series could have gone: exacting detail on the Stuarts, their families, how beautiful Carol was, how it all went wrong — on other words, on Charles' decision to kill her and his brother's decision to turn him in. Instead, it wisely focuses not on the murder itself, but on the police investigation, both its origins and the deep scars it left. The bulk of the first installment is spent on the history of segregation and racism in Boston, with particular focus on the ugly protests against busing as a way to desegregate public schools. It's a bit of a salutary bait-and-switch, seeming like another true-crime story, but really taking this case and using it as only one example of much broader problems. The result is far more satisfying and substantial.
The three-episode docuseries is a standard format by now, particularly on Netflix. That's how many episodes Netflix has of Bad Vegan and Escaping Twin Flames and Bad Surgeon. It's how many there are of Max's own Love Has Won. These often follow a three-act structure: the setup, the explosive events, the consequences and conclusions. Murder in Boston suggests what might be a better path for a series like this, which calls all the way back to Ezra Edelman's outstanding series O.J.: Made in America. That series, while it was longer, similarly used its long format to provide what is often missing from stories about true crime, or scandals, or headlines of the past: context.
Yes, it's possible to spend three episodes synthesizing what we know about events of the past, primarily for the benefit of people who either want to look back on them as familiar or want to learn about them because they weren't around the first time. But why set aside the benefit time can often provide, which is a chance to gain new perspective on familiar stories?
Journalists and civil rights leaders, and one retired police officer who was willing to talk — and who seems to have zero regrets about his role in the manhunt — speak to the ways the aftermath of this killing changed the city, how it echoes in conversations that still take place now, and how, in retrospect, biases and failures of imagination prevented a mostly white police apparatus from being suspicious about Stuart's story when plenty of Black residents never believed it for a minute. (For all this useful context, it also is undeniably an advantage to this series that the old COPS-like show Rescue 911 was filming with Boston emergency medical services on the night of the murder, which means there is much more footage than usual of the crime scene, of Charles Stuart being loaded into the ambulance and being treated in the hospital, and of him muttering about the supposed Black carjacker.)
This is what a docuseries should look like. Events are covered efficiently; context is given room to breathe, to occupy the space it needs. A lot of such projects are disposable and sensational, offering less light than heat. But this is one that gets the balance right.
This piece also appeared in NPR's Pop Culture Happy Hour newsletter. Sign up for the newsletter so you don't miss the next one, plus get weekly recommendations about what's making us happy.
Listen to Pop Culture Happy Hour on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.
veryGood! (96949)
Related
- Mike Tyson vs. Jake Paul stirs debate: Is this a legitimate fight?
- Many Americans padded their savings amid COVID. How are they surviving as money dries up?
- Well-known leader of a civilian ‘self-defense’ group has been slain in southern Mexico
- Vanderpump Rules' Jax Taylor Has a Special Invitation for Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce
- New Pentagon report on UFOs includes hundreds of new incidents but no evidence of aliens
- US announces sanctions against a group of 10 Hamas members and financial network over Israel attack
- Former Wisconsin Senate clerk resigned amid sexual misconduct investigation, report shows
- The Fate of Kim Zolciak's $6 Million Mansion Revealed Amid Kroy Biermann Divorce
- Man jailed after Tuskegee University shooting says he fired his gun, but denies shooting at anyone
- AP PHOTOS: The death toll soars on war’s 11th day, compounding misery and fueling anger
Ranking
- US wholesale inflation picks up slightly in sign that some price pressures remain elevated
- Four killed in multicar crash on Pacific Coast Highway in Malibu
- More US ships head toward Israel and 2,000 troops are on heightened alert. A look at US assistance
- Wolfgang Van Halen marries Andraia Allsop in ceremony that honors his late father Eddie Van Halen
- The Bachelorette's Desiree Hartsock Gives Birth, Welcomes Baby No. 3 With Chris Siegfried
- Pennsylvania prison officials warned of 'escape risk' before Danelo Cavalcante breakout
- Former Virginia House Speaker Filler-Corn will forego run for governor and seek congressional seat
- Disney attorneys want to question former administrator in lawsuit with DeSantis appointees
Recommendation
-
Jenn Tran's Ex Devin Strader Throws Shade At Her DWTS Partner Sasha Farber Amid Romance Rumors
-
Aces starters Chelsea Gray and Kiah Stokes out for Game 4 of WNBA Finals vs. Liberty
-
US Rep. Debbie Lesko won’t seek re-election in Arizona next year
-
Arkansas orders Chinese company’s subsidiary to divest itself of agricultural land
-
Taking stock of bonds: Does the 60/40 rule still have a role in retirement savings?
-
Former Wisconsin Senate clerk resigned amid sexual misconduct investigation, report shows
-
DC Young Fly’s Sister Dies 4 Months After His Partner Jacky Oh
-
Police fatally shoot armed fugitive who pointed gun at them, authorities say