Current:Home > StocksIndigenous Land Rights Are Critical to Realizing Goals of the Paris Climate Accord, a New Study Finds-Angel Dreamer Wealth Society D1 Reviews & Insights
Indigenous Land Rights Are Critical to Realizing Goals of the Paris Climate Accord, a New Study Finds
View Date:2024-12-23 16:30:19
The land rights of Indigenous peoples across millions of acres of forests in Brazil, Colombia, Mexico and Peru must be protected and strengthened if the world has any hope of achieving the goals set forth in the 2015 Paris Agreement, a study released on Thursday found.
The study, by the World Resources Institute and Climate Focus, two non-profit global research organizations focused on alleviating climate change, supports a growing body of research emphasizing the important role Indigenous peoples and other local communities play in mitigating greenhouse gas emissions and protecting biodiversity.
In Brazil, for instance, the government would need to take 80 percent of vehicles off the roads to account for the carbon dioxide kept in the forests on Indigenous and local communities’ lands, the report said.
But instead of including Indigenous communities when devising plans to meet goals under the Paris Agreement, governments have largely ignored the role those communities play in meeting emission reductions targets, according to the report.
Worse, the report said, governments have carried out policies that make it more difficult for Indigenous communities to obtain title over their land, and have enabled harassment and assaults against those communities by failing to protect Indigenous peoples’ rights.
Juan-Carlos Altamirano, an economist at WRI and one of the report’s authors, said safeguarding the rights of Indigenous peoples and local communities is critical to averting the climate crisis. Each additional degree of global warming—accelerated by the loss of Indigenous lands—increases the risk of floods, drought, sea level rise and other extreme weather events.
“The challenge of meeting the Paris Agreement will be enormous if Indigenous and local communities’ lands are lost,” Altamirano said.
Indigenous-Held Forests Absorb Twice As Much Carbon
Scientists have long been aware that forests trap carbon dioxide within trees’ leaves, branches, trunks and roots. That’s why keeping forests intact has been part of global plans to combat climate change. When trees are destroyed through fires or clear cutting, forests can become a source of climate-warming greenhouse gas emissions as once-sequestered carbon is released into the atmosphere.
But when it comes to capturing and keeping carbon in the ground, not all forests are equal.
Using data from Global Forest Watch, a forest monitoring website, and Landmark, a Lima-based organization that monitors and maps Indigenous-held land, the study’s authors looked the forests in Peru, Brazil, Colombia and Mexico to find out how well forests on Indigenous and local communities’ land sequestered carbon compared to other forested lands. Those countries are home to some of the most biologically diverse forests in the world.
The researchers compared the net amounts of carbon dioxide released and stored on Indigenous and local communities’ lands against other forested lands from 2000 to 2020. They found that, on average, Indigenous-held forests absorbed over twice as much carbon dioxide as other forested lands, such as land owned by governments or private parties.
The country with the biggest difference was Brazil, where, on average, non-Indigenous land emits about 10 metric tons of carbon dioxide equivalent per hectare while Indigenous land sequesters about 30 metric tons of carbon dioxide equivalent per hectare.
The researchers also found that 92 percent of Indigenous and local communities’ land in the countries studied were “net sinks,” meaning they absorb more carbon dioxide than they emit. Without those contributions, governments would have to make up the emissions reductions elsewhere.
“Brazil and Colombia would have to retire 80 percent of their vehicle fleet and Mexico would need to retire 35 percent of its vehicle fleet to account for the loss of carbon sequestration services provided by Indigenous peoples and local communities’ lands, whereas Peru would have to retire their entire vehicle fleet to make up for just half of the loss of Indigenous peoples and local communities’ contributions,” the report said.
Governments Leave Indigenous Communities Out of Paris Plans
Despite the outsized role Indigenous and local communities play in sequestering carbon emissions, Peru, Colombia, Mexico and Brazil have largely excluded those communities from their emission reduction plans, the researchers found.
A misnomer about the Paris Agreement is that, on the whole, it is not binding. Countries that have ratified the agreement are required to prepare successive “nationally determined contribution” plans (NDCs) that outline how they will achieve their emission and adaptation goals. The idea is that by requiring countries to increase their commitments over time, the world can meet its long term goal to limit global warming.
But, in each of the four countries studied, laws and policies towards Indigenous peoples falls far short of protecting Indigenous lands and in some cases, actively works against it.
In Brazil, President Jair Bolsonaro put a hold on demarcations, or identification, of Indigenous lands and has supported legislation that would open up Indigenous lands to extractive industries.
In Mexico and Colombia, the government can permit extractive activity on Indigenous lands without obtaining the approval of those Indigenous communities.
And in Peru, the process for identifying Indigenous lands is so administratively cumbersome that it can take up to 20 years to complete. About a third of Indigenous and local communities’ land in the country is still unrecognized, leaving those groups vulnerable to wild cat miners and other land invasions.
The researchers said these and other harmful policies have contributed to illegal deforestation on Indigenous lands and the murders and harassment of Indigenous peoples. In 2020, 65 environmental defenders were killed in Colombia, 30 in Mexico, 20 in Brazil and six in Peru, according to data from the nonprofit Global Witness. The vast majority of those alleged crimes have gone unpunished.
The Road Ahead
Altamirano said that while the report focuses on Indigenous and local communities’ land, a larger message is that humans must protect all forests, regardless of who manages them, to achieve goals under the Paris Agreement.
The problem of “leakage,” when a policy to stop deforestation in one place leads to deforestation elsewhere, is a concern. If deforestation on Indigenous lands stops, it could lead to greater rates of deforestation in other woodlands.
Altamirano said to prevent leakage, policy makers should aim to protect forests in a way that recognizes communities that depend on them for their livelihoods and promote sustainable forest management—something Indigenous communities have effectively done for thousands of years.
By bringing Indigenous communities into climate policy making at local, national and international levels, he said, there is a greater chance that their knowledge can be shared and expanded to non-indigenous land management.
For the international community and wealthy countries like the United States, ensuring that forest-protection funding goes to Indigenous and local communities is key, Altamirano and his co-author, Darragh Conway, said.
“Living in harmony with nature is essentially written into these communities’ DNA,” Conway, a lawyer with WRI, said. “When donors are funding forest protection, they need to make sure that money comes down to the local level because ultimately, these communities that live there are the ones best placed to protect forests.”
veryGood! (9671)
Related
- Black and Latino families displaced from Palm Springs neighborhood reach $27M tentative settlement
- Will Captain Sandy Yawn Get Married on Below Deck Mediterranean? She Says...
- A Georgia trucker survived a wreck, but was killed crossing street to check on the other driver
- Bengals QB Joe Burrow leaves game against Ravens in 2nd quarter with wrist injury
- Mike Tomlin's widely questioned QB switch to Russell Wilson has quieted Steelers' critics
- Horoscopes Today, November 16, 2023
- Democratic Party office in New Hampshire hit with antisemitic graffiti
- Oakland mourns Athletics' move, but owner John Fisher calls it a 'great day for Las Vegas'
- Target will be closed on Thanksgiving: Here’s when stores open on Black Friday
- The judge in Trump’s Georgia election case limits the disclosure of evidence after videos’ release
Ranking
- Elton John Details Strict Diet in His 70s
- TGL dome slated for new Tiger Woods golf league loses power, collapses
- Hip-Hop mogul Sean Combs accused of trafficking, sexual assault and abuse in lawsuit
- Missouri’s voter ID law is back in court. Here’s a look at what it does
- 'I know how to do math': New Red Lobster CEO says endless shrimp deal is not coming back
- Soldier, her spouse and their 2 children found dead at Fort Stewart in Georgia
- Federal charges added for Georgia jail escapee and woman accused of helping him
- AP Week in Pictures: Europe and Africa
Recommendation
-
Kate Spade Outlet’s Early Black Friday Sale – Get a $259 Bag for $59 & More Epic Deals Starting at $25
-
90 Day Fiancé’s Darcey Silva Marries Georgi Rusev in Private Ceremony
-
Tiger Woods cheers on son in first state golf championship: How Charlie earned his stripes
-
Starbucks Red Cup Day is sheer stress for workers. We're going on strike because of it.
-
California teen pleads guilty in Florida to making hundreds of ‘swatting’ calls across the US
-
India bus crash kills almost 40 as passengers plunged 600 feet down gorge in country's mountainous north
-
Story of a devastating wildfire that reads ‘like a thriller’ wins Baillie Gifford nonfiction prize
-
Backpage founder Michael Lacey convicted of 1 money laundering count