Current:Home > Contact-usAI’s future could be ‘open-source’ or closed. Tech giants are divided as they lobby regulators-Angel Dreamer Wealth Society D1 Reviews & Insights
AI’s future could be ‘open-source’ or closed. Tech giants are divided as they lobby regulators
View Date:2024-12-23 23:33:51
Tech leaders have been vocal proponents of the need to regulate artificial intelligence, but they’re also lobbying hard to make sure the new rules work in their favor.
That’s not to say they all want the same thing.
Facebook parent Meta and IBM on Tuesday launched a new group called the AI Alliance that’s advocating for an “open science” approach to AI development that puts them at odds with rivals Google, Microsoft and ChatGPT-maker OpenAI.
These two diverging camps — the open and the closed — disagree about whether to build AI in a way that makes the underlying technology widely accessible. Safety is at the heart of the debate, but so is who gets to profit from AI’s advances.
Open advocates favor an approach that is “not proprietary and closed,” said Darío Gil, a senior vice president at IBM who directs its research division. “So it’s not like a thing that is locked in a barrel and no one knows what they are.”
WHAT’S OPEN-SOURCE AI?
The term “open-source” comes from a decades-old practice of building software in which the code is free or widely accessible for anyone to examine, modify and build upon.
Open-source AI involves more than just code and computer scientists differ on how to define it depending on which components of the technology are publicly available and if there are restrictions limiting its use. Some use open science to describe the broader philosophy.
The AI Alliance — led by IBM and Meta and including Dell, Sony, chipmakers AMD and Intel and several universities and AI startups — is “coming together to articulate, simply put, that the future of AI is going to be built fundamentally on top of the open scientific exchange of ideas and on open innovation, including open source and open technologies,” Gil said in an interview with The Associated Press ahead of its unveiling.
Part of the confusion around open-source AI is that despite its name, OpenAI — the company behind ChatGPT and the image-generator DALL-E — builds AI systems that are decidedly closed.
“To state the obvious, there are near-term and commercial incentives against open source,” said Ilya Sutskever, OpenAI’s chief scientist and co-founder, in a video interview hosted by Stanford University in April. But there’s also a longer-term worry involving the potential for an AI system with “mind-bendingly powerful” capabilities that would be too dangerous to make publicly accessible, he said.
To make his case for open-source dangers, Sutskever posited an AI system that had learned how to start its own biological laboratory.
IS IT DANGEROUS?
Even current AI models pose risks and could be used, for instance, to ramp up disinformation campaigns to disrupt democratic elections, said University of California, Berkeley scholar David Evan Harris.
“Open source is really great in so many dimensions of technology,” but AI is different, Harris said.
“Anyone who watched the movie ‘Oppenheimer’ knows this, that when big scientific discoveries are being made, there are lots of reasons to think twice about how broadly to share the details of all of that information in ways that could get into the wrong hands,” he said.
The Center for Humane Technology, a longtime critic of Meta’s social media practices, is among the groups drawing attention to the risks of open-source or leaked AI models.
“As long as there are no guardrails in place right now, it’s just completely irresponsible to be deploying these models to the public,” said the group’s Camille Carlton.
IS IT FEAR-MONGERING?
An increasingly public debate has emerged over the benefits or dangers of adopting an open-source approach to AI development.
Meta’s chief AI scientist, Yann LeCun, this fall took aim on social media at OpenAI, Google and startup Anthropic for what he described as “massive corporate lobbying” to write the rules in a way that benefits their high-performing AI models and could concentrate their power over the technology’s development. The three companies, along with OpenAI’s key partner Microsoft, have formed their own industry group called the Frontier Model Forum.
LeCun said on X, formerly Twitter, that he worried that fearmongering from fellow scientists about AI “doomsday scenarios” was giving ammunition to those who want to ban open-source research and development.
“In a future where AI systems are poised to constitute the repository of all human knowledge and culture, we need the platforms to be open source and freely available so that everyone can contribute to them,” LeCun wrote. “Openness is the only way to make AI platforms reflect the entirety of human knowledge and culture.”
For IBM, an early supporter of the open-source Linux operating system in the 1990s, the dispute feeds into a much longer competition that precedes the AI boom.
“It’s sort of a classic regulatory capture approach of trying to raise fears about open-source innovation,” said Chris Padilla, who leads IBM’s global government affairs team. “I mean, this has been the Microsoft model for decades, right? They always opposed open-source programs that could compete with Windows or Office. They’re taking a similar approach here.”
WHAT ARE GOVERNMENTS DOING?
It was easy to miss the “open-source” debate in the discussion around U.S. President Joe Biden’s sweeping executive order on AI.
That’s because Biden’s order described open models with the highly technical name of “dual-use foundation models with widely available weights” and said they needed further study. Weights are numerical parameters that influence how an AI model performs.
“When the weights for a dual-use foundation model are widely available — such as when they are publicly posted on the Internet — there can be substantial benefits to innovation, but also substantial security risks, such as the removal of safeguards within the model,” Biden’s order said. He gave U.S. Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo until July to talk to experts and come back with recommendations on how to manage the potential benefits and risks.
The European Union has less time to figure it out. In negotiations coming to a head Wednesday, officials working to finalize passage of world-leading AI regulation are still debating a number of provisions, including one that could exempt certain “free and open-source AI components” from rules affecting commercial models.
veryGood! (78356)
Related
- BITFII Introduce
- Cannabis sales in Minnesota are likely to start later than expected. How much later isn’t clear
- Woman whose husband killed his 5-year-old daughter granted parole for perjury
- Mega Millions lottery jackpot up to 6th largest ever: What to know about $687 million drawing
- New York nursing home operator accused of neglect settles with state for $45M
- What to know about Kate Cox: Biden State of the Union guest to spotlight abortion bans
- Baltimore to pay $275k in legal fees after trying to block far-right Catholic group’s 2021 rally
- Starbucks launches spring menu, including 2 new iced lavender drinks
- Wind-whipped wildfire near Reno prompts evacuations but rain begins falling as crews arrive
- NBA announces the Phoenix Suns will host the 2027 All-Star game
Ranking
- Keke Palmer Says Ryan Murphy “Ripped” Into Her Over Scream Queens Schedule
- This 'Euphoria' star says she's struggled with bills after Season 3 delays. Here's why.
- NFL Network's Good Morning Football going on hiatus, will relaunch later this summer
- Feds investigating suspected smuggling at Wisconsin prison, 11 workers suspended in probe
- John Robinson, successful football coach at USC and with the LA Rams, has died at 89
- WWE Alum and Congressional Candidate Daniel Rodimer Accused of Murder by Las Vegas Police
- Powerball winning numbers for March 6, 2024 drawing: Jackpot rises to $521 million
- Putin’s crackdown casts a wide net, ensnaring the LGBTQ+ community, lawyers and many others
Recommendation
-
It's cozy gaming season! Video game updates you may have missed, including Stardew Valley
-
Mega Millions lottery jackpot up to 6th largest ever: What to know about $687 million drawing
-
Kate Middleton's Uncle Speaks to Her Health Journey While on Celebrity Big Brother
-
Automaker Rivian pauses construction of its $5 billion electric truck plant in Georgia
-
Cameron Brink set to make Sports Illustrated Swimsuit debut
-
Houston police chief apologizes for department not investigating 264K cases due to staffing issues
-
BBC Scotland's Nick Sheridan Dead at 32
-
Proposed transmission line for renewable power from Canada to New England canceled