Current:Home > Contact-usGeorgia Senate considers controls on school libraries and criminal charges for librarians-Angel Dreamer Wealth Society D1 Reviews & Insights
Georgia Senate considers controls on school libraries and criminal charges for librarians
View Date:2024-12-23 14:46:31
ATLANTA (AP) — A proposal that would require school libraries to notify parents of every book their child checks out was advanced by Georgia senators Tuesday, while a proposal to subject school librarians to criminal charges for distributing material containing obscenity waits in the wings.
The measures are part of a broad and continuing push by Republicans in many states to root out what they see as inappropriate material from schools and libraries, saying books and electronic materials are corrupting children.
Opponents say it’s a campaign of censorship meant to block children’s freedom to learn, while scaring teachers and librarians into silence for fear of losing their jobs or worse.
Georgia senators are also considering bills to force all public and school libraries in the state to cut ties with the American Library Association and to restrict school libraries’ ability to hold or acquire any works that depict sexual intercourse or sexual arousal. Neither measure has advanced out of committee ahead of a deadline next week for bills to pass out of their originating chamber.
The state Senate Education and Youth Committee voted 5-4 Tuesday to advance Senate Bill 365 to the full Senate for more debate. The proposal would let parents choose to receive an email any time their child obtains library material.
Sen. Greg Dolezal, the Republican from Cumming sponsoring the bill, said the Forsyth County school district, which has seen years of public fighting over what books students should be able to access, is already sending the emails. Other supporters said it was important to make sure to guarantee the rights of parents to raise their children as they want.
“I can’t understand the resistance of allowing parents to know what their children are seeing, doing and participating in while they’re at school, especially in a public school system,” said Senate Majority Leader Steve Gooch, a Dahlonega Republican.
Opponents said it’s important for students to be able to explore their interests and that the bill could violate students’ First Amendment rights.
“This is part of a larger national and Georgia trend to try to limit access,” said Nora Benavidez, a lawyer for PEN America, a group that supports free expression. “The logical endpoint of where this bill, as well as others, are taking us is for children to have less exposure to ideas.”
The proposal to make school librarians subject to criminal penalties if they violate state obscenity laws, Senate Bill 154, is even more controversial. Current law exempts public librarians, as well as those who work for public schools, colleges and universities, from penalties for distributing material that meets Georgia’s legal definition of “harmful to minors.”
Dolezal argues that school librarians should be subject to such penalties, although he offered an amendment Tuesday that makes librarians subject to penalties only if they “knowingly” give out such material. He argues that Georgia shouldn’t have a double standard where teachers can be prosecuted for obscenity while librarians down the hall cannot. He said his real aim is to drive any such material out of school libraries.
“The goal of this bill is to go upstream of the procurement process and to ensure that we are not allowing things in our libraries that cause anyone to ever have to face any sort of criminal prosecution,” Dolezal said.
Supporters of the bill hope to use the threat of criminal penalties to drive most sexual content out of libraries, even though much sexual content doesn’t meet Georgia’s obscenity standard.
“If you are exploiting children, you should be held accountable,” said Rhonda Thomas, a conservative education activist who helped form a new group, Georgians for Responsible Libraries. “You’re going to find that our students are falling behind in reading, math, science, but they’re definitely going to know how to masturbate.”
Robert “Buddy” Costley, of the Georgia Association of Educational Leaders, said the bill won’t solve the content problems that activists are agitated about.
“My fear is is that if we tell parents that this is the solution — your media specialists, the people that have been working for 200 years in our country to loan books, they’re the problem — we will have people pressing charges on media specialists instead of dealing with the real problem,” Costley said.
veryGood! (176)
Related
- Black, red or dead: How Omaha became a hub for black squirrel scholarship
- New findings revealed in Surfside condo collapse investigation
- Joseph Fiordaliso, who championed clean energy as head of New Jersey utilities board, dies at 78
- Former crypto executive the latest to face charges in collapse of FTX exchange
- Flurry of contract deals come as railroads, unions see Trump’s election looming over talks
- Investigators say a blocked radio transmission led to a June close call between planes in San Diego
- Severe flooding in Greece leaves at least 6 dead and 6 missing, villages cut off
- Stock market today: Asian shares fall as China reports weaker global demand hit its trade in August
- Giuliani’s lawyers after $148M defamation judgment seek to withdraw from his case
- Why No. 3 Alabama will need bullies or a magician for its showdown against No. 10 Texas
Ranking
- Missing Ole Miss student declared legally dead as trial for man accused in his death looms
- Philanthropies pledge $500 million to address 'crisis in local news'
- Mission underway to rescue American who fell ill while exploring deep cave in Turkey
- Suspect serial killer arrested in Rwanda after over 10 bodies found in a pit at his home
- Prosecutors say some erroneous evidence was given jurors at ex-Sen. Bob Menendez’s bribery trial
- Deion Sanders, Colorado start fast with rebuild challenging college football establishment
- AG investigates death of teens shot by deputy
- As Climate-Fueled Weather Disasters Hit More U.S. Farms, the Costs of Insuring Agriculture Have Skyrocketed
Recommendation
-
College Football Playoff ranking release: Army, Georgia lead winners and losers
-
'No words': 9/11 death toll continues to rise 22 years later
-
Former Finnish prime minister Sanna Marin, who was one of Europe’s youngest leaders, quits politics
-
Larry Birkhead Says Anna Nicole Smith Would Be So Proud of Daughter Dannielynn in 17th Birthday Message
-
US overdose deaths are down, giving experts hope for an enduring decline
-
Actor Gary Busey allegedly involved in hit-and-run car accident in Malibu
-
Grizzly bear suspected of maulings near Yellowstone area killed after breaking into house
-
Judge halts California school district's transgender policy amid lawsuit