Current:Home > ScamsU.S. plan for boosting climate investment in low-income countries draws criticism-Angel Dreamer Wealth Society D1 Reviews & Insights
U.S. plan for boosting climate investment in low-income countries draws criticism
View Date:2024-12-23 21:54:58
A plan the United States floated Wednesday to increase private investment for clean energy in low-income countries is being met with skepticism from financial experts and environmentalists.
Under the proposed Energy Transition Accelerator, companies would be able to buy carbon credits from developing nations that are cutting their greenhouse gas emissions. A carbon credit represents a set amount of emissions that were reduced or removed from the atmosphere. Companies would buy the credits to offset their own emissions.
Details of the State Department plan are still being fleshed out, but it appears countries would generate credits by cutting emissions in their power sectors through the retirement of fossil fuel infrastructure like coal plants and the addition of renewable energy. Countries would then be able to sell the credits to corporations. Those transactions would create a reliable source of money for low-income countries, which they could use to obtain additional private funding on favorable terms, the U.S. State Department said in a statement.
The goal of the program is to "establish a high-integrity framework enabling developing countries to attract finance to support their clean energy transitions," the State Department said.
Critics say carbon markets — the places where carbon credits are bought and sold — often fail to deliver climate benefits. In some cases, there are concerns that credits are double counted, which happens when two parties are able to claim the emissions reductions from a single credit. That leads to overstating the credit's actual environmental benefit.
Under the State Department initiative, emissions reductions would serve two purposes: Creating carbon credits to sell to private investors, and helping low-income countries meet their international climate pledges, known as nationally determined contributions.
A U.S. official said the plan would comply with guidelines set out in the Paris Agreement on climate change that are intended to prevent double counting.
Some climate experts said the plan is still problematic.
Rachel Cleetus of the Union of Concerned Scientists said it's inconsistent with the need to make "steep, absolute emission reductions as soon as possible" in order to limit global warming.
"Carbon offsets are not an answer in a world already on fire, under water and facing mounting climate losses and damage," Cleetus said in a statement.
Many climate advocates say low-income countries need to get money directly in the form of grants that don't further strain their national budgets.
"That's what the U.S. must deliver, rather than questionable carbon offset schemes that risk allowing companies to pollute at the expense of the planet," Cleetus said.
Robin Rix, an executive at Verra, a nonprofit that sets standards for carbon markets, said the U.S. plan needs "rigorous" guidelines to attract private investors and ensure money isn't going to projects that would have otherwise gotten funding.
The U.S. announced its plan a day after the United Nations took aim at companies that use "dishonest climate accounting" practices.
The U.N. said in a report released during its annual climate conference that companies that have promised to eliminate or offset their carbon emissions should cut their own emissions instead of buying carbon credits whose effectiveness is hard to verify.
The State Department said its new program could be limited to companies that have committed to eliminating or offsetting their emissions by 2050, with science-based interim targets. The department said it is considering other measures to "promote environmental integrity" in how the credits are used.
The program is expected to run through 2030, with the possibility to extend it to 2035, the department said.
"Done right, leveraging voluntary carbon markets can help unlock billions of dollars from the private sector to accelerate the energy transition," Ani Dasgupta, CEO of World Resources Institute, said in a statement. However, there's "a reason that carbon offsets have been associated with greenwashing, which must absolutely be avoided."
veryGood! (6)
Related
- Isiah Pacheco injury updates: When will Chiefs RB return?
- Horoscopes Today, January 8, 2024
- Taco Bell unveils new value menu with food as low as $1.99: See the new menu items
- California man gets 4 years in prison for false sex assault claims against Hollywood executives
- Skai Jackson announces pregnancy with first child: 'My heart is so full!'
- An Englishman's home has flooded nearly a dozen times in 7 years. He built a wall to stop it from happening again.
- Reactions to the death of German soccer great Franz Beckenbauer at the age of 78
- Julianne Moore and Natalie Portman Respond to Vili Fualaau's May December Criticism
- Target will be closed on Thanksgiving: Here’s when stores open on Black Friday
- JetBlue’s CEO is stepping down, and he’ll be replaced by the first woman to lead a big US airline
Ranking
- Olivia Munn Randomly Drug Tests John Mulaney After Mini-Intervention
- 'Scientifically important': North Dakota coal miners stumble across mammoth tusk, bones
- Paris names a street after David Bowie celebrating music icon’s legacy
- Emergency at 3 miles high: Alaska Airlines pilots, passengers kept calm after fuselage blowout
- Ex-Marine misused a combat technique in fatal chokehold of NYC subway rider, trainer testifies
- The Only 3 Cleaning Products You’ll Ever Need, Plus Some Handy Accessories
- US fugitive accused of faking his death to avoid rape charges is booked into a Utah jail
- Expert predictions as Michigan and Washington meet in CFP national championship game
Recommendation
-
Powell says Fed will likely cut rates cautiously given persistent inflation pressures
-
'Break Point' Season 2: Release date, cast, how to watch pro tennis docuseries
-
Newly sworn in, Louisiana’s governor calls for special session to draw new congressional map
-
California Gov. Gavin Newsom sets date for special election to replace Rep. Kevin McCarthy
-
Garth Brooks wants to move his sexual assault case to federal court. How that could help the singer.
-
Murder charge dismissed ahead of trial after 6 years
-
US Supreme Court declines to hear 2nd Illinois case challenging state’s ban on semiautomatic weapons
-
Worker-owed wages: See the top companies, professions paying out the most unclaimed back wages