Current:Home > FinanceSenate Republican blocks bill that would protect access to IVF nationwide-Angel Dreamer Wealth Society D1 Reviews & Insights
Senate Republican blocks bill that would protect access to IVF nationwide
View Date:2024-12-24 00:34:37
Washington — One Senate Republican on Wednesday scuttled a Democrat-led effort to pass legislation that would safeguard access to IVF nationwide.
The bill aims to preempt state efforts to restrict access to the fertility treatments since a ruling earlier the Alabama Supreme Court ruled earlier this month that frozen embryos could be considered children under a state law. The decision made it possible for couples whose frozen embryos were accidentally destroyed to sue for wrongful death of their "extrauterine children." The ruling has paused IVF treatments and processes in the state as providers evaluate their liability.
Sen. Tammy Duckworth, an Illinois Democrat, sought to approve the legislation under unanimous consent, which gives any single lawmaker the power to block its passage. The bill would create federal protections for IVF access nationwide, after access to the fertility treatment often used by women who struggle to become pregnant has come into question under state law in Alabama. Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith, a Mississippi Republican blocked the bill on Wednesday.
"The bill before us today is a vast overreach that is full of poison pills that go way too far," Hyde-Smith said on the Senate floor after she objected to the bill's passage.
Duckworth first introduced the legislation, known as the Access to Family Building Act, with Sen. Patty Murray in 2022. The move on Wednesday marked the second time Duckworth has brought the bill to the Senate floor for a vote after she attempted to pass it by unanimous consent in 2022. At the time, Hyde-Smith also opposed.
Although many Senate Republicans oppose the Alabama ruling and have thrown their support behind IVF, some have argued that the issue should be decided by states. But it is threatening to become a liability for Republicans. Polls show that large majorities of Americans from both parties favor access to IVF.
Meanwhile, Democrats have tied the issue to abortion, viewing it as a new front in the battle over abortion access since the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade in 2022.
"Donald Trump suddenly supports IVF after crowing and claiming and taking credit for the fall of Roe v. Wade. You can't do both," Duckworth said at a news conference on Tuesday.
Sen. Richard Blumenthal, a Connecticut Democrat, told reporters ahead of the vote that he expected Democrats to "keep at it" if Republicans blocked the bill.
"We trust women to make decisions about their own reproductive health care," he said. "And the IVF dilemma for Republicans is they are down a path that is not only unpopular, it's untenable as a matter of constitutional law and basic moral imperative, and we're gonna pursue it vigorously."
At least 16 states have proposed personhood bills that could impact access to IVF treatments, according to the Guttmacher Institute, a research group that studies reproductive health rights.
Legal experts caution that even state laws might not be enough.
"There's a possibility that whatever the legislature does will be challenged as violating the rights of fetal persons," said Mary Ziegler, a professor at the University of California Davis School of Law.
IVF advocates on Wednesday also rallied on the steps of the Alabama State House, urging lawmakers to protect IVF providers from civil and criminal prosecution.
Among them was Sarah Houston, who had her uterus removed after a diagnosis of cervical cancer. Wanting another child, she endured the painful and expensive IVF process. An embryo was going to be transferred to a surrogate in March. Following the Alabama Supreme Court's ruling, however, it is now on hold.
"It's heartbreaking to feel like it was that close," Houston said. "And then now to kind of feel like maybe we're even back at the beginning."
Houston is holding onto hope for another child. Amid her cancer struggle, her children Vi and Henry give her infinite joy.
"They're awesome, and being a mom is awesome," Houston said, adding that not getting that opportunity again "would be devastating."
"Obviously an embryo transfer doesn't mean that it's a guarantee that you'll end up with a baby," Houston said. "But without that, there's no hope of us having a baby."
— Janet Shamlian and Alan He contributed reporting.
- In:
- United States Congress
- IVF
Kaia Hubbard is a politics reporter for CBS News Digital based in Washington, D.C.
veryGood! (7)
Related
- Man who stole and laundered roughly $1B in bitcoin is sentenced to 5 years in prison
- Mark Robinson vows to rebuild his staff for North Carolina governor as Republican group backs away
- The Daily Money: Holiday shoppers are starting early
- What time is 'The Voice' on? Season 26 premiere date, time, coaches, where to watch and stream
- Denver district attorney is investigating the leak of voting passwords in Colorado
- Sean Diddy Combs Predicts His Arrest in Haunting Interview From 1999
- California bans all plastic shopping bags at store checkouts: When will it go into effect?
- Memphis man testifies that he and another man killed rapper Young Dolph
- Joan says 'Yes!' to 'Golden Bachelorette' finale fantasy beach proposal. Who did she pick?
- Man fatally shot by police in Connecticut appeared to fire as officers neared, report says
Ranking
- US Open finalist Taylor Fritz talks League of Legends, why he hated tennis and how he copied Sampras
- Donna Kelce Reacts After Being Confused for Taylor Swift's Mom Andrea Swift
- Review: Zachary Quinto medical drama 'Brilliant Minds' is just mind-numbing
- Exclusive: Watch 'The Summit' learn they have 14 days to climb mountain for $1 million
- Opinion: NFL began season with no Black offensive coordinators, first time since the 1980s
- Feds bust Connecticut dealers accused of selling counterfeit pills throughout the US
- Gunman who killed 10 at a Colorado supermarket found guilty of murder
- Boyd Gaming buys Resorts Digital online gambling operation
Recommendation
-
'Joker 2' actor pans DC sequel as the 'worst film' ever: 'It has no plot'
-
You'll Be Sliving for Paris Hilton's Adorable New Video of Son Phoenix
-
Southeast US under major storm warning as hurricane watch issued for parts of Cuba and Mexico
-
'Boy Meets World' star Trina McGee suffers miscarriage after getting pregnant at age 54
-
Nevada trial set for ‘Dances with Wolves’ actor in newly-revived sex abuse case
-
What are Instagram Teen Accounts? Here's what to know about the new accounts with tighter restrictions
-
ONA Community’s Vision and Future – Comprehensive Investment Support for You
-
Volunteers help seedlings take root as New Mexico attempts to recover from historic wildfire