Current:Home > InvestJudge strikes down recent NYC rules restricting gun licensing as unconstitutional-Angel Dreamer Wealth Society D1 Reviews & Insights
Judge strikes down recent NYC rules restricting gun licensing as unconstitutional
View Date:2024-12-23 23:06:30
NEW YORK (AP) — A federal judge on Tuesday struck down recent provisions in New York City’s gun restrictions as unconstitutional, saying officials have been allowed too much discretion to deny gun permits to people deemed “not of good moral character.”
Judge John P. Cronan in Manhattan said in a written ruling that the “magnitude of discretion” afforded to city gun licensing officials under facets of the city’s administrative code violated the Constitution’s 2nd and 14th amendments.
In particular, the judge cited provisions empowering officials to evaluate an applicant’s “good moral character” and whether “good cause exists for the denial” of gun permits.
The ruling added the city to the growing number of municipalities nationwide whose gun restrictions have been struck down after a landmark U.S. Supreme Court ruling in June 2022 found that Americans have a right to carry firearms in public for self-defense.
The Supreme Court’s so-called Bruen decision, which struck down a New York gun law, was the high court’s first major gun decision in over a decade. It has led to lower courts striking down various gun laws and prompted the Supreme Court earlier this year to agree to decide whether judges are going too far in striking down restrictions on firearms.
The judge said he was staying the effect of his ruling until midnight Thursday to give the city time to appeal.
The ruling came in a lawsuit filed last year by Joseph Srour, who was denied a permit to possess rifles and shotguns in his home by officials who cited prior arrests, bad driving history and alleged false statements on applications.
Cronan wrote that the case was “not about the ability of a state or municipality to impose appropriate and constitutionally valid regulations governing the issuance of firearm licenses and permits.”
“Rather,” he said, “the provisions fail to pass constitutional muster because of the magnitude of discretion afforded to city officials in denying an individual their constitutional right to keep and bear firearms,” and because the city failed to show that unabridged discretion is grounded in the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation.
He said notices that Srour received from the New York Police Department’s gun licensing division “are not models of clarity in explaining the precise legal grounds for denying his applications to possess firearms.”
The regulations that Cronan found to be unconstitutional have since been amended and the judge said he was not yet ruling on the wording of the new provisions.
The city did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
Amy Bellantoni, Srour’s attorney, said in a text message that Cronan’s decision resulted from “rock solid constitutional analysis.”
She called it “a major win for self protection in New York City.”
In written arguments in February asking Cronan to rule against Srour, city lawyers said his gun permit application was denied because he “lacked candor” by omitting two prior arrests and prosecutions, one for attempted murder, as well as an “egregious history of moving violations demonstrating an inability to comply with licensing requirements.”
Cronan cited last year’s Supreme Court Bruen ruling in his decision, saying the vaguely worded “good cause” provision in New York City’s rules were “much like” the “proper cause” wording invalidated by the Supreme Court in its decision last year.
He said the provisions he struck down were written so that “a licensing official would make a judgment call about the character, temperament and judgment of each applicant without an objective process.”
“Without doubt, the very notions of ‘good moral character’ and ‘good cause’ are inherently exceedingly broad and discretionary. Someone may be deemed to have good moral character by one person, yet a very morally flawed character by another. Such unfettered discretion is hard, if not impossible, to reconcile with Bruen,” Cronan wrote.
veryGood! (148)
Related
- Bull doge! Dogecoin soars as Trump announces a government efficiency group nicknamed DOGE
- 'Joker 2' is 'startlingly dull' and Lady Gaga is 'drastically underused,' critics say
- Noah Centineo reveals when he lost his virginity. There's no right age, experts say.
- Peacock's star-studded 'Fight Night' is the heist you won't believe is real: Review
- Why Game of Thrones' Maisie Williams May Be Rejoining the George R.R. Martin Universe
- Behati Prinsloo's Sweet Photos of Her and Adam Levine's Kids Bring Back Memories
- Markey and Warren condemn Steward’s CEO for refusing to comply with a Senate subpoena
- FBI received tips about online threats involving suspected Georgia shooter | The Excerpt
- CRYPTIFII Introduce
- Louisiana legislators grill New Orleans DA for releasing people convicted of violent crimes
Ranking
- Minnesota man is free after 16 years in prison for murder that prosecutors say he didn’t commit
- Buffalo’s mayor is offered a job as president and CEO of regional Off-Track Betting Corporation
- Matthew McConaughey's Son Levi Proves He's Following in His Dad's Footsteps With First Acting Role
- Anna Delvey on 'DWTS' leaves fans, Whoopi Goldberg outraged by the convicted scam artist
- CFP bracket prediction: SEC adds a fifth team to field while a Big Ten unbeaten falls out
- What's at stake in Michigan vs. Texas: the biggest college football game of Week 2
- Behati Prinsloo's Sweet Photos of Her and Adam Levine's Kids Bring Back Memories
- Shop Madewell’s Under $50 Finds & Save Up to 67% on Fall-Ready Styles Starting at $11
Recommendation
-
Kevin Costner says he hasn't watched John Dutton's fate on 'Yellowstone': 'Swear to God'
-
Travis Kelce Shares How His Family Is Navigating Fame Amid Taylor Swift Romance
-
I’m a Shopping Editor, and These Are the Doc Martens Shoes Everyone Needs in Their Fall Wardrobe
-
Boeing Starliner to undock from International Space Station: How to watch return to Earth
-
Roy Haynes, Grammy-winning jazz drummer, dies at 99: Reports
-
An ex-Mafia hitman is set for sentencing in the prison killing of gangster James ‘Whitey’ Bulger
-
A 13-foot (and growing) python was seized from a New York home and sent to a zoo
-
Taylor Swift hasn't endorsed Trump or Harris. Why do we care who she votes for?