Current:Home > MyPennsylvania high court revives a case challenging Medicaid limits for abortions-Angel Dreamer Wealth Society D1 Reviews & Insights
Pennsylvania high court revives a case challenging Medicaid limits for abortions
View Date:2024-12-23 16:28:16
HARRISBURG, Pa. — Pennsylvania's Supreme Court said Monday that a lower court must hear a challenge to the constitutionality of a decades-old state law that limits the use of Medicaid dollars to cover the cost of abortions, a major victory for Planned Parenthood and the abortion clinic operators who sued.
The decision also elicited hope that the state Supreme Court may one day find a right to abortion in Pennsylvania's constitution after the U.S. Supreme Court ended nearly a half-century of federal abortion protections by overturning Roe v. Wade.
The 3-2 decision both overturns a lower court decision to dismiss the case on procedural grounds and puts aside a 1985 state Supreme Court decision that upheld a law banning the use of state Medicaid dollars for abortion, except in cases of rape, incest or to save the life of the mother.
Alexis McGill Johnson, Planned Parenthood Federation of America's president and CEO, called the decision a "landmark victory for reproductive freedom."
The high court's majority said Monday in a 219-page decision that prior court decisions did not fully consider the breadth of state constitutional protections against discrimination, beyond those provided by the federal constitution.
The lawsuit, brought in 2019 by Planned Parenthood and other operators of abortion clinics, said the 1982 law unconstitutionally discriminates against poor women.
"Today's ruling is the first step toward ending discriminatory access to care, and we remain committed to removing every barrier to abortion," Signe Espinoza, executive director of Planned Parenthood of Pennsylvania's policy arm, said in a statement.
The state House's Republican floor leader, Rep. Bryan Cutler, had opposed the lawsuit in court and on Monday accused the state Supreme Court of "seeking to overstep its authority and change well-settled law."
The new ruling does not necessarily find a constitutional right to an abortion in Pennsylvania, where abortion is legal under state law through 23 weeks of pregnancy.
Rather, it turns on the question of whether the state Medicaid law unconstitutionally singled out a procedure sought only by women and differentiated between women who carry to term and women who get an abortion.
Women who get an abortion receive no government funding for the reproductive care they seek, while women who carry to term receive full coverage, the majority opinion said. Seventeen other states cover abortion in their state Medicaid programs, the court said.
The lower Commonwealth Court had said in its 2022 decision that it was bound by the prior state Supreme Court decision in dismissing the lawsuit.
But the majority said the lower court must now reconsider the case under a more stringent constitutional standard.
That part of the majority opinion was written by Justice Christine Donohue and joined by Justices David Wecht and Dougherty. Dissenting were Chief Justice Debra Todd and Justice Sally Mundy, the lone Republican to take part in the decision.
Todd and Mundy disagreed that the high court had issued a flawed decision in 1985. In her dissent, Mundy wrote that the 1985 decision was "well-considered, restrained and appropriate," and preserved the balance of power between the judicial and legislative branches.
That balance will be upset, however, if the court prevents lawmakers from advancing a state interest — for instance, encouraging childbirth over abortion — by prioritizing how to spend public money, Mundy wrote.
Justices Kevin Brobson and Daniel McCaffery joined the bench after the case was argued and didn't participate in the decision.
In one part of the majority opinion, Donohue made it clear that she sees a state constitutional right to abortion in the existing structure of Pennsylvania's constitution.
"We conclude that the Pennsylvania Constitution secures the fundamental right to reproductive autonomy, which includes a right to decide whether to have an abortion or to carry a pregnancy to term," Donohue wrote.
Wecht joined that part of the opinion. However, the other three justices did not.
Dougherty said he agreed with Todd and Mundy that the case is not about the right to an abortion, but qualified it in his written opinion by saying "at least, not yet."
David S. Cohen, a constitutional law professor at Drexel University's law school who helped argue the case, acknowledged that a majority of the court didn't find a fundamental right to abortion in Pennsylvania.
But, Cohen said, the issue will come back to the court in the future "and we now have a great building block to accomplish that goal."
veryGood! (191)
Related
- Diamond Sports Group can emerge out of bankruptcy after having reorganization plan approved
- Parents say they could spend more than $36K on child care this year: 'It doesn't make sense'
- Hulu is about to crack down on password sharing. Here's what you need to know.
- Aircraft laser strike reports soar to record high in 2023, FAA says
- Opinion: NFL began season with no Black offensive coordinators, first time since the 1980s
- Powerball winning numbers for Wednesday night's drawing: Jackpot climbs to $206 million
- Biden to celebrate his UAW endorsement in Detroit, where Arab American anger is boiling over Gaza
- Jennifer Lopez, Lady Gaga and More Stars Whose Daring Grammys Looks Hit All the Right Notes
- The USDA is testing raw milk for the avian flu. Is raw milk safe?
- 'That '70s Show' actor Danny Masterson moved to maximum security prison that once held Charles Manson
Ranking
- Kate Spade Outlet’s Early Black Friday Sale – Get a $259 Bag for $59 & More Epic Deals Starting at $25
- Kentucky House committee passes bill requiring moment of silence in schools
- 2024 NBA Draft expands to two-day format: second round will be held day after first round
- USC, UCLA, ACC highlight disappointments in men's college basketball this season
- FBI raids New York City apartment of Polymarket CEO Shayne Coplan, reports say
- Parents arrested in case of social media model charged with killing boyfriend
- Former NBA All-Star Marc Gasol officially announces retirement from basketball
- 'Apples Never Fall' preview: Annette Bening, Sam Neill in latest Liane Moriarty adaptation
Recommendation
-
Statue of the late US Rep. John Lewis, a civil rights icon, is unveiled in his native Alabama
-
FDA warns of contaminated copycat eye drops
-
'That '70s Show' actor Danny Masterson moved to maximum security prison that once held Charles Manson
-
Hinton Battle, who played Scarecrow in Broadway's 'The Wiz,' dies at 67 after long illness
-
DWTS' Gleb Savchenko Shares Why He Ended Brooks Nader Romance Through Text Message
-
A beheading video was on YouTube for hours, raising questions about why it wasn’t taken down sooner
-
Premature birth rate rose 12% since 2014, the CDC reports. A doctor shares what to know.
-
TikTok, Snap, X and Meta CEOs grilled at tense Senate hearing on social media and kids