Current:Home > NewsSupreme Court kills Biden's student debt plan in a setback for millions of borrowers-Angel Dreamer Wealth Society D1 Reviews & Insights
Supreme Court kills Biden's student debt plan in a setback for millions of borrowers
View Date:2024-12-23 21:49:10
Follow NPR's live coverage for the latest updates and reaction to this opinion.
In a highly anticipated decision, the Supreme Court on Friday struck down President Biden's groundbreaking plan to forgive some or all federal student loan debt for tens of millions of Americans.
By a 6-to-3 vote on ideological lines, the high court ruled that federal law does not authorize the Department of Education to cancel such student loan debt.
Writing for the majority, Chief Justice John Roberts said: "The authority to 'modify' statutes and regulations allows the Secretary to make modest adjustments and additions to existing provisions, not transform them."
Siding with the states, Justice Amy Coney Barrett said, in her concurring opinion, said the major questions doctrine "reinforces" the majority's conclusion "but is not necessary to it."
In her dissent, Justice Elena Kagan criticized the court's "overreach, and noted she would have decided the states didn't have the right to sue.
"The plaintiffs in this case are six States that have no personal stake in the Secretary' loan forgiveness plan," she said. "They are classic ideological plaintiffs: They think the plan a very bad idea, but they are no worse off because the Secretary differs."
Last August, President Biden told federal student loan borrowers that the U.S. government would cancel up to $20,000 of debt for low income students who had received a Pell Grant to attend college, and up to $10,000 for the vast majority of remaining borrowers. He cited a 2001 law that allows the Secretary of Education "to alleviate the hardship that federal student loan recipients may suffer as a result of national emergencies." That is the same law that President Trump used to freeze federal student loan payments and interest accrual due to the COVID pandemic.
Soon after Biden's announcement, however, six states filed a lawsuit to stop the implementation of the debt cancellation plan, arguing that Biden exceeded his authority under the federal law. The Supreme Court ultimately stepped in to review the case.
The high court's ruling signifies another example of its expanding use of the "Major Questions Doctrine," the idea that Congress must speak very clearly when granting power to executive agencies like the Department of Education to make decisions about issues that are politically or economically significant. And, as the doctrine says, if there is any ambiguity to whether Congress has granted this power, courts should not presume that Congress did so. Last year, the high court struck down the Secretary of Labor's vaccine mandate on these grounds.
The decision comes as a disappointment to federal student loan borrowers who were eligible for relief under the plan — as many as 43 million borrowers, or roughly 1 in 8 Americans.
Come fall, student loan interest accrual and payments will begin again, affecting borrowers in all 50 states.
veryGood! (625)
Related
- After years of unrest, Commanders have reinvented their culture and shattered expectations
- Amazon pauses construction in Virginia on its second headquarters
- Boy, 10, suffers serious injuries after being thrown from Illinois carnival ride
- A trip to the Northern Ireland trade border
- Quincy Jones' Cause of Death Revealed
- Phoenix shatters yet another heat record for big cities: Intense and unrelenting
- See Chris Pratt and Son Jack’s Fintastic Bonding Moment on Fishing Expedition
- Want to Elect Climate Champions? Here’s How to Tell Who’s Really Serious About Climate Change
- California voters reject measure that would have banned forced prison labor
- Why some Indonesians worry about a $20 billion climate deal to get off coal
Ranking
- Teachers in 3 Massachusetts communities continue strike over pay, paid parental leave
- Warming Trends: Cacophonous Reefs, Vertical Gardens and an Advent Calendar Filled With Tiny Climate Protesters
- Rebel Wilson and Fiancée Ramona Agruma Will Need a Pitch Perfect Compromise on Wedding Plans
- Moderna's COVID vaccine gambit: Hike the price, offer free doses for uninsured
- Florida Man Arrested for Cold Case Double Murder Almost 50 Years Later
- Miranda Lambert paused a concert to call out fans taking selfies. An influencer says she was one of them.
- Succession and The White Lotus Casts Reunite in Style
- A multiverse of 'Everything Everywhere' props are auctioned, raising $555K for charity
Recommendation
-
Powerball winning numbers for Nov. 13 drawing: Jackpot rises to $113 million
-
Farming Without a Net
-
Warming Trends: A Potential Decline in Farmed Fish, Less Ice on Minnesota Lakes and a ‘Black Box’ for the Planet
-
Global Warming Can Set The Stage for Deadly Tornadoes
-
Patrick Mahomes Breaks Silence on Frustrating Robbery Amid Ongoing Investigation
-
Berta Cáceres’ Murder Shocked the World in 2016, But the Killing of Environmental Activists Continues
-
Over $30M worth of Funkos are being dumped
-
A Silicon Valley lender collapsed after a run on the bank. Here's what to know