Current:Home > NewsWisconsin judge affirms regulators can force factory farms to get preemptive pollution permits-Angel Dreamer Wealth Society D1 Reviews & Insights
Wisconsin judge affirms regulators can force factory farms to get preemptive pollution permits
View Date:2024-12-23 16:53:14
MADISON, Wis. (AP) — A Wisconsin judge ruled Tuesday that state regulators can force factory farms to obtain permits before they discharge pollutants, ensuring protections continue to apply preemptively for lakes, streams and drinking water.
Calumet County Circuit Judge Carey Reed issued the decision from the bench in a lawsuit brought by factory farm lobbyists, finding the state Department of Natural Resources has clear legal authority to protect the state’s waters.
“This ruling is critical because it preserves the DNR’s ability to address water pollution that can be caused by these facilities, at a time when many surface and groundwaters around the state are contaminated with animal waste,” said Evan Feinauer, an attorney with environmental advocacy group Clean Wisconsin. “Allowing large dairies to sidestep oversight would have been catastrophic for water protection in our state.”
Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce, the state’s largest business group, filed a lawsuit in Calumet County in May on behalf of the Wisconsin Dairy Alliance and the Venture Dairy Cooperative, two groups that lobby for factory farms.
The groups challenged the DNR’s authority to impose mandates through factory farms’ water pollution permits such as monitoring groundwater pollution levels, implementing manure management plans and limiting herd sizes. Last year the agency scaled back S&S Jerseyland Dairy’s request to expand from roughly 5,000 cows to 10,000 cows, allowing the operation to add only about 2,400 animals.
The plaintiffs alleged that federal courts in 2005 and 2011 struck down the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s authority to require factory farms obtain permits before they actually discharge contaminants into navigable waters. Therefore, the groups argued, the DNR’s requirement that factory farms obtain permits before the fact was also invalid because it now conflicted with federal law.
The groups’ interpretation would have allowed factory farms greater freedom to increase herd sizes and contaminate state waters with chemicals such as nitrates and phosphates from manure and other fertilizers.
Reed sided with the DNR, pointing to a section of state law that declares Wisconsin policy calls for restoring and maintaining the integrity of its waters to protect public health and aquatic wildlife.
WMC spokesperson Nick Novak declined to comment on the ruling.
The farming industry and environmentalists have been locked in a fierce back-and-forth over regulating factory farms, defined as farms with at least 1,000 beef cattle, 715 dairy cows or 200,000 chickens. According to the state Department of Natural Resources, more than 330 such farms are currently permitted to operate in Wisconsin.
Conservationists say factory farms produce massive amounts of manure that contaminate groundwater, streams and creeks. Industry advocates counter that regulations are too strict and stifle growth.
Clean Wisconsin and the Wisconsin Farmers Union, a group that lobbies for sustainable farming, joined the case as intervenors. Environmental law firm Midwest Environmental Advocates represented that group in the proceedings.
“We are pleased that the circuit court upheld longstanding clean water protections and rejected this reckless lawsuit,” Midwest Environmental Advocates staff attorney Adam Voskuil said in a statement. “The claims advanced by Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce and their clients would have exposed rural Wisconsinites and small family farmers to illegal manure discharges, polluting their drinking water and Wisconsin’s rivers and lakes.”
veryGood! (7414)
Related
- Richard Allen found guilty in the murders of two teens in Delphi, Indiana. What now?
- Panama’s Supreme Court declares 20-year contract for Canadian copper mine unconstitutional
- Taylor Swift's the 'Eras Tour' movie is coming to streaming with three bonus songs
- Lightning strikes kill 24 people in India amid unusually heavy rain storms in Gujarat state
- Human head washes ashore on Florida beach, police investigating: reports
- Chinese AI firm SenseTime denies research firm Grizzly’s claim it inflated its revenue
- Kenosha man gets life in prison for fatally stabbing his father, stepmother with a machete in 2021
- Jimmy Carter set to lead presidents, first ladies in mourning and celebrating Rosalynn Carter
- 4 arrested in California car insurance scam: 'Clearly a human in a bear suit'
- “Carbon Cowboys” Chasing Emissions Offsets in the Amazon Keep Forest-Dwelling Communities in the Dark
Ranking
- World War II veteran reflects on life as he turns 100
- Kenosha man gets life in prison for fatally stabbing his father, stepmother with a machete in 2021
- Kate Spade 24-Hour Flash Deal: This $300 Backpack Is on Sale for $65 and It Comes in 4 Colors
- Freed Israeli hostage describes deteriorating conditions while being held by Hamas
- NASCAR Cup Series Championship race 2024: Start time, TV, live stream, odds, lineup
- Stephen Colbert forced to sit out 'Late Show' for a week due to ruptured appendix
- Official who posted ‘ballot selfie’ in Wisconsin has felony charge dismissed
- Sumatran rhino, critically endangered species, gives birth at Indonesian sanctuary: Watch
Recommendation
-
Pitchfork Music Festival to find new home after ending 19-year run in Chicago
-
Beware, NFL coaches: Panthers' job vacancy deserves a major warning label
-
High stakes and glitz mark the vote in Paris for the 2030 World Expo host
-
Elon Musk visits Israel amid discussions on Starlink service in Gaza
-
Trump hammered Democrats on transgender issues. Now the party is at odds on a response
-
Sierra Leone’s leader says most behind the weekend attacks are arrested, but few details are given
-
Live updates | Israel and Hamas extend truce, agree to free more hostages and prisoners
-
The tragic cost of e-waste and new efforts to recycle